Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra vs iRobot Roomba i5+

A detailed side-by-side comparison scored on 14 objective criteria with weighted scoring (max 12 points).

WINNER

Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra

Roborock — #8 overall

8.1/10

$899

iRobot — #34 overall

5.2/10

$349

Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra is the clear winner, outscoring iRobot Roomba i5+ by 2.9 points. However, iRobot Roomba i5+ has 61% cheaper.

Criteria	Weight	Roborock S8 MaxV Ultra	iRobot Roomba i5+
Total Score	—	8.1/10	5.2/10
🗺️Navigation & Obstacle Tech	2x	92%*	60%
💨Suction Power	1x	90%*	75%
📐Edge Cleaning	1x	88%*	70%
💇Tangle-Free Rollers	1x	85%*	78%
🧹Mop System	1x	85%*	0%
🔥Mop Drying	0.5x	85%*	0%
🧴Integrated Soap	0.5x	80%*	0%
🔄Mop Versatility	0.5x	50%*	0%
🗑️Auto-Empty Reliability	1x	90%*	80%
📦Bin Capacity	0.5x	85%*	72%
⏱️Refill Frequency	0.5x	85%*	75%
🧗Obstacle Mobility	1x	40%*	30%
📏Low Clearance	0.5x	45%	55%*
📱App Quality	1x	92%*	70%
Price	—	$899	$349
Pros		+Excellent value when on sale ($899) +Strong all-around performer +LiDAR + AI camera avoidance +Matter smart home support	+Affordable Roomba +Self-emptying base +iRobot reliability +Good for simple layouts
Cons		-Large dock requires space -Mopping not quite as good as Matrix10 -MSRP is expensive ($1,799)	-No smart mapping -Basic navigation -No mopping
Suction		6,000 Pa	2,000 Pa
Navigation		LiDAR + Camera + AI Avoidance	Basic
Mop Type		Sonic + Auto-Wash	None
Self-Empty		Yes (60 days)	Yes (60 days)
Runtime		180 min	75 min
Mobility
Obstacle Climbing		Standard	Standard
Retractable LiDAR		No	No
Adaptive Chassis		No	No
Multi-Mop Switch		No	No
		Check Price Full Review	Check Price Full Review